Kawasaki Motorcycle Forums banner

Bike Oil vs Car Oil...

13766 Views 55 Replies 26 Participants Last post by  keeber
Yeah, yeah, I KNOW what the issues are – the wet clutch, the transmission etc etc – but does anybody have experience with extended use of (decent) car oil in their bike? The situation here is that a decent “Bike Oil” is three or more times the price of a decent car oil. (I like Mobil products because of the excellent detergent properties.) If I compare Mobil 4T Semi-Synth 4 stroke Motorcycle Oil with Mobil Super S Semi-Synth Oil. The Super S is API-SJ (on a par with Mobil 1 !) while 4T is SF or SG (can't remember which). Those are OLD specs that you might only see on cheap no-name car oils! WTF?! I like to change the oil regularly, making the price of the bike oil a big issue…
Let me know what your opinion or experience is (and please say if it is an opinion or experience – thanx)

:wink:
21 - 40 of 56 Posts
anyone try amsoil in their bikes? i tried it once in my moms car at the track and liked it. didnt notice any difference from mobil1 though.
Many people use Amsoil in their cars and bikes, without any problem that I have heard of. Some swear by it.
The drain interval on Amsoil is very long. But I can't stand to leave ANY oil in the crankcase longer than 3 months or 3,000 miles on a car. On a bike, 1000 miles is the limit for me. I can probably let it go longer, but it gives me confidence that clean oil is always circulating in something that you depend heavily on.
Regards
I use Redline exclusively in my 350Z, because I race it (autocross and track days). Redline is in a similar class as Amsoil, i.e. the next level above Mobil 1. If I'm putting 200 miles on the track with my car, the engine pretty much screaming between 4000 and 6700 RPM the entire time (oh what an excellent sound!), I want some serious engine protection. I have not been disappointed with Redline.

I'm seriously debating whether to start pouring the Redline into my bike as well. This thread has pretty much convinced me that there isn't any special magical property motorcycle oil has that a very high-end car oil doesn't. My only concern would be problems with the clutch. Does anyone have anymore information on that issue?
You should not use an automotive oil that is marked as "energy conserving" in your bike. Such oils contain friction additives, such as molybdenum, which would likely cause clutch slippage/damage. Now the "gray" area. There are automotive oils that are not marked as energy conserving that bikers have been using for years. All the companies make such oils, and they come in weights like 20W50, 15W50, etc. The viscosity spread is larger than those of the energy conserving oils, which require less of the viscosity index improvers (which is one reason these oils are energy conserving) than the oils with a wider viscosity spread. To confuse matters further, the different API grades, SH SJ SL, etc. all represent an ongoing decrease (even in the motorcycle-specific oils) in phosphorous/zinc, which is the ultimate protector of metal-to-metal contact, should that occur. We are told that the stuff might be ultimately bad for our catalytic convertors. But even momentary metal-to-metal contact can occur in car or bike, i.e. overheating or a microsecond of starvation in a small, critical area for example. I take the path that the more phosphorous/zinc additives, the potentially better it is for our bikes. Yes, bikers have been using auto oil for years, but with this recent ongoing reduction in the protective additives, what does the future hold for engine wear for people who use auto oil in their bikes? I really don't know. At least during warranty, use a bike-specific oil. Otherwise, any repairs that are deemed to be oil-faiilure related will not be covered. I use only bike oil and change it out at 1000 miles. Some use Mobil 1 15W-50, and state that they have had good luck with it.
See less See more
hey michael, how do u like the 350's preformance at the track? ive seen a couple at the track i go to and they're pretty quick, xcept they have serious brake problems:p smoke is always pouring from the wheels when they pull into the pit:p:p:p i also saw a g35 at the track and he snapped his rear lower control arm. says its the second time its happened!?!
I LOVE my Z. It's perfect for the track. It's extremely well balanced and easy to control. They definitely spent a lot of track time while putting it together.

Even stock it handles pretty **** well, but it understeers a bit, to keep the weekend warriors from putting their cars in the ditch. I replaced the sway bars, put on Koni shocks and new springs. The handling now is exceptional. I don't think this car gives up anything to the Vettes in handling, even though it's not as powerful in the engine department. Even still, it has a really nice flat torque curve, and loves digging out of tight corners.

I usually drive my street tires on the track, but when I autocross I have a set of Hoosiers. This car is amazing with race rubber on it. I find myself doing stuff that my brain says shouldn't be possible, like full-throttle into offsets, bouncing off the rev limiter before the exit, near full throttle into long sweepers, etc. It's a helluva lot of fun. My bike is going to be hard pressed to exceed that fun quotient when I get it on the track next summer. :)

I have never seen a broken control arm. Is he doing something exceptionally hard on the car? Is he not being smooth? It's all about smooth if you want to be fast.

Yes, brakes are probably the biggest liability on this car. They work fine for street and autocross, but on the track, more brakes are needed. But that's often the case with almost every car. A set of Stoptechs fixes that real nicely. :)
See less See more
Back in the 80's I used valvoline 10w40 in my kz 650 with no problem. As I got older I have been useing Amzoil motorcycle 10 w 40 in my bikes. I use synthetic in all my vehicles with great luck so far.
Castrol Ow30 German-made PAO oil, no friction mods $5 @ Autozone here in the US is at least as good as anything Mobil 1, costs less, smells better :)

I have used this in every bike I own and cars for the last 5 years and all my vehicles have close to 200K miles and none of my 4T bikes needed anything.
It's closer to a 40 weight oil when hot, but pours at like negative 100 Celsius.....

IMO it's the perfect car oil for bikes at a great value. I think Castrol markets this stuff under another brand name, but it is what it is, German Castrol.

Redline and Amsoil are "boutique" oils, great but they should be @ 10 bux or more a quart....Amsoil = Amway with their MLM marketing schemes.
Prove to me that they are better than any other PAO synthetic and I'll buy you a six-pack of your fave beverage. I want to see used oil analysis numbers from each (actually I have) given the application.
You should not use an automotive oil that is marked as "energy conserving" in your bike. Such oils contain friction additives, such as molybdenum, which would likely cause clutch slippage/damage.
Small amounts of Moly have been shown to be beneficial in bikes without causing any problems with Wet Clutches. Do a google search. It's a myth.

Friction additives and Viscosity Improvers are two different things.....in an energy conserving oil such as 5W30, etc VIs are what makes the temperature swing possible so you can have the 5W when cold.

If you really want to educate some people, search for Bobistheoilguy and go to their bike section
I have used this in every bike I own and cars for the last 5 years
In that case you started using this just about the time this thread was started and ended or at least left for dead. :tongue:
Yeah, yeah, I KNOW what the issues are – the wet clutch, the transmission etc etc – but does anybody have experience with extended use of (decent) car oil in their bike?
29 years in mine (since it was brand new) all I have used is car oil. castrol GTX way back in the old days before synthetic, then switched to synthetic oil later when it became available.

29 years, 76k miles.
I've got 52K on my 01 Vulcan and except for the first oil change have always used Castrol 10w40 and a fram filter available at my local auto parts store. I change it every 2500 miles. No problems with engine, clutch, or transmission operation to date. My perspective is changing oil frequently supercedes issues with breakdown of the molicules.
Motorcycle oil is what you should use. You can probably pick up a case & defray some of the cost.
Phosphorous and zinc are the primary lubricants in motorcycle oil. Calcium and magnesium are the acid neutralizers that are added. Each "upgrade" of the API level (SF, SG, SH) means less phosphorous levels. What that means in the long run, I don't know. They feel that the phosphorous content may contribute to shortened catalytic converter life.
You can buy those additives at Kragen's or Pep Boys in the little bottles. STP has a ton of it, there are others like Rislone and the rest. Some of them say right on the bottle they contain tha dditives that gradually deplete from oil and recommend using them after a couple of thousand miles to "restore" the oil.
An oil thread never dies or fades away.
An oil thread never dies or fades away.
It just gradually loses it's viscosity....
Yes but some weights lose their viscosity faster than others ;)

from www.BurgmanUSA.com :: View topic - Is it okay to use synthetic oil? (What type should I use?)

Conventional 10w-40 oil has a viscosity range of 30 (40-10). Same as 20w-50. But to get the 10w-40 viscosity requires adding more viscosity improver (VI) polymers than for 20w-50 oil. So what? It means that 10w-40 conventional oil has less oil in a liter than does 20w-50. Less oil to lubricate. Which is why GM stopped recommending 10w-40 oil after finding a lot of engine problems with it. the following are a start on the topic:
BMCNO Motor Oil 101
all_oilfaq_v1.2
Pelican Technical Article: Street Dyno
You can buy those additives at Kragen's or Pep Boys in the little bottles. STP has a ton of it, there are others like Rislone and the rest. Some of them say right on the bottle they contain tha dditives that gradually deplete from oil and recommend using them after a couple of thousand miles to "restore" the oil.
They are called "snake oil". Never use anything you can buy at a store in your oil. The oil companies are doing a good job and generally don't need any help by backyard chemists (AKA Lucas Oil "products"...like cheese "product" it's not real oil)
I've been the black sheep on many of these threads.
Used car oil in my bikes for many years.
Even rode a couple with automatic transmission fluid in them for a couple years. One of those years was in Germany on the autobahn.
I had very few stock bikes.
Only went to syn oil last year when i went turbo.
An oil thread never dies or fades away.
Especially when noobs resurrect them.
Especially when noobs resurrect them.
the reason why oil threads are relevent (even old ones) is because the cost
of all oil products have increased, along with the fact that "green" is now the color of popularity. The less used oil released in the enviroment, the better off our kids are (note the recent San Fran Bay disaster). I am by no means a tree hugger, but educating yourselves about something that is reusable is smart.

Not to mention better performance / longevity about using superior products for longer periods between changes.

I might be a noob here but not new to using a wrench or a computer which it seems many can do one but not both around these parts :lol:

I'll end my contribution by saying this: Guessing a how a product performs is like gambling . You may get away with it for a long time, but you'll eventually lose money. Used Oil Analysis is the only way to know how a oil performs in a given application. That's the way truck fleets and race teams do it, so if you don't want to emulate heavy or performance users such as these, then take it to a dealership mechanic.
Companies like blackstone charge $20 bucks. Do it once every 6 months or when you change oils/weights and you'll know what works the best for you and your bike/car/tractor/lawnmower.
See less See more
21 - 40 of 56 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top