I have purchased many carbs off of Amazon, mostly because they still have all the adjustments that the EPA has taken out, and have never returned one. I also use "Jack's Small Engines", a Google search will show the website, and I have also purchased carbs for engines that I have made manifolds, and got them running excellent. I rarely have spent more than $80 bucks. Carbs are not easy to set up if you don't have the knowledge. Setting up an OEM carb may be easier since it's usually sent with factory settings (but not all the time).
If you have the money to spend, then always go the OEM route, you save yourself a lot of trouble. I don't know if he still has the OEM carb, but I would think that would be rebuildable. At $670 bucks,, it should be.. I think that there's more going on here. The fact that Amazon has the EXACT carb replacement,
and so many of them for that Mule means that it is a common part. Some of those Chinese parts are made very well, and that's because they were Chinese made to begin with. No carb will work if you do not know how to set it up.
